Thursday, May 25, 2006

RESERVATION DESERVATION!!!!

Reservation incidentally is not the idea of an India whose time has come. The repercussion of the political decision for reserving half of the quotas for the scheduled castes and tribes has starkly divided the nation into educational ghettoization. This certainly does not augur well for a nation that so very well is trying to root its paws into the den of developed nations.

More importantly, this does not hold good for the tomorrow of a nation which seems inspiringly proud of having in possession the youngest dormant human resource pool available across nations.
The oft repeated plagiarized quote by our Prime Minister Dr. MM Singh sounds so much a farce at this point in time. To put it accordingly – “An idea whose time has come”

This certainly is not a blueprint whose time has come, Dear Sir.

Reservation subjected to caste is an initiative that has had to be aborted at the fetal stage itself. Or rather an idea which should not have been impregnated into the minds at the first place!

What are we talking about? Reservations in the name of caste!?
Honestly speaking, as an inspired nation, we do not expect us (read: India) to be led by mindsets pertaining to the 18th century! The obesity of eccentricities by a bundle of jokers sitting at the helm of affair is very perplexing!

There are some exceptions to the rule though. And the exceptions are distinctly well laid when it comes to reservations. Provide enough and equal opportunities for “reserved” ones from primary and high school levels, so that they could be in great competition amongst equals!
After all, no nation can afford to rest assured its future on semi-boiled talents.
Also provide opportunities (economical as well as social security) to the real latent potentials amongst these camps that are oblivious in this muddle of caste and creed.

Surely, there would be academic gems in the scheduled castes and tribes too. Scout for these talents, nurture them at nascent stages, condition them to succeed and then watch the bloom of a nation showering out from a rainbow of talents.

Reservation on the basis of caste! The sooner we dump those fuddy-duddy baggages, the better it would be promises for our nation. As the thumping cliché the generation next has been vociferously sloganeering - “Let merit be the deciding factor and not the womb!”

Now let us shift our focus on another aspect. But equally knitted with this paraphernalia of “reservations”!
This would be one of the most hilariously ridiculous prepositions any nation would have faced.

A year back, our Honorable Prime Minister unveiled a project which he made everyone believe was a dream project.
Christened – NATIONAL KNOWLEDGE COMMISSION
Goal – Advise the Prime Minister on matters relating to institutions of knowledge production, knowledge use and knowledge dissemination.
Mandate of the commission – To sharpen India’s “knowledge edge”.

Now does this have any place in our country where in a class of hundred, 50 would be burning the midnight oil to get well placed into respectable positions in the society and the other half would be as relaxed as ever, comfortably squatting on the sofa called reservations.

Reservations in premier and specialized institutions today might percolate into private sectors the day after tomorrow. This is very much a possibility looking at the way the politics of our country functions or rather malfunctions.

To relate an anecdote -

During my sojourn to Pune recently, the gentleman with whom I had the pleasure of sharing my seat was an alumnus of the prestigious IIT – Kanpur who was also presently pursuing his MBA from IIM – Ahemadabad (both on merit basis).
The journalist in me cringed to take his views on this whole reservation debate.

If his thoughts on reservations could be taken as a symbolic representation of what runs through the minds of the students who have made through the merit list vis-à-vis, the reserved lists, we could well come up with some conclusion on whether to put this thing in or to dump the issue in the bin.

“Personally if you ask me, I would say that it is ridiculous for us to still debate on this issue of reservation based on caste. During my engineering at IIT (K) most of the students who came on the so called “quota” were so casual about their studies. And mind, you they were not from families who could not afford them the luxuries of a good life. They belonged to rich families and had all the pleasures of living. Not saying that there were not any students from the list who did not do well, but most of them took things so nonchalantly and relaxed. Some of them have been there for years”.

Let everyone play on an equal field. Do not elevate the field for somebody just on the basis of their caste or birth.

The people who are for the reservation bill say that since India has 50% of SC and ST’s, and only 15% of general merit class, there has been huge injustice for them in terms of reservation.
Well said. The point is respected.
In that case, an out of the box solution is to be thought with respect to the reservation issue.

Maybe we should make the whole country OBC or Other Backward Class!
After all in the world’s eye, we seem to be going backwards anyways, right Mr. Arjun Singh?

9 Comments:

Blogger Dewaker Basnet said...

ice n fire...yeah do agree with you..:) you love to believe in a few things..equality of opportunity being one of them..:)
innovatve thinking..wow..feel like a molecular scientist ;)

7:18 pm

 
Blogger Keshi said...

**Reservation on the basis of caste!

I saw this issue in many blogs...but whoever in the Indian govt came up with this DUMBEST and the most SHALLOW idea?

Keshi.

9:29 pm

 
Blogger Neha said...

every blog, every school college, every newspaper, magazine yada yada yada, is accusing the govenrnment of commiting a horrendous crime like this. but tell me, doesn't 50% reserved seats also mean 50% votes??
end of story.
bill is passed.

11:59 pm

 
Blogger Dewaker Basnet said...

keshi: yeah whoever thought about it....now the bill is apparently pased:(

neha: yeah neha everyone is writing it so i too pitched in...30 years down the line i would remember this day when my kids would not get a fair chance just because they do not belong to the reserved class...sad day for India..sad day for the idea of India

5:19 am

 
Blogger FumingSalmon said...

a good one dewaker...just that too technically sound(literary sense)..i had to read a couple of lines twice to get the meaning :)

Reservation has become the word i hate so much...it has starting symbolizing sumthing wrong to me...n i hv decided that i wud stop using it from now...thanx to Indian policy makers...

These r the same politicians who send their kids abroad for studies so they hardly knw the anxiety parents hv to go thru to get admissions for their kids...

already there is loads of competition becoz of mamoth population..imagine half a million ppl appeared for AIEEE exam this year...with ths reservation in place...donno what hell sum of these students will hv to thru...

its all crap and wish i cud just pack these politicians in a rocket, send them to mars n let them make n implement their policies there...i guess India wud b better off without them...

man these r ppl without brains, common sense n conscience...

i had Big expectations from our PM, i have read his writings, i thought here comes a PM who has head on his shoulders...he is the biggest blooper of this century...

With bill almost passed i hv so hopes regarding this..n i m sure this is my last comment on this topic...me sad !!

i m already worried abt my kids n their education...1 more tension in basket of every Indian...a hell more on their way...

9:52 am

 
Blogger Rujuta said...

It's no wonder politicians themselves get treated by doctors in foreign countries...

12:59 pm

 
Blogger Neha said...

i agree with u dewakar but tell me, what is it that we haven't done...written to those blind people, spoken to those deaf people, went for hunger strike, taken all kinds of torture, but what is the outcome?? so many young people have given their life for it, but what has been done about it??? even i hate the very concept of it from the bottom of ma heart like any 'unreserved' citizen, but all these people are concerned is their FUCKING VOTES!

9:52 pm

 
Blogger Dewaker Basnet said...

rujuta: youve made a very imp. point..how true..

neha: i understand competerly whatever you are saying and also do fully empathize with you...the brighter side of it is that the number of people who are concerned about the country and its future is on a definite rise..thats nice that we are participating and giving out our best in as possible ways as possible to put forth our opinion..

as far as the politicians..the average age at present is almost close to 75...

They too will pass away soon..
LITERALLY :)

10:43 pm

 
Blogger brute said...

i only wish ....theres a permanent solution for this reservation issue

9:25 pm

 

Post a Comment

<< Home